Lesson 3 of 3
Deposits without scaring guests
By the end: Choose a deposit amount, refund window and scope, and test whether it pays for your room.
A deposit puts money behind a booking. The worry is fair: it may also put some guests off booking at all. This lesson shows what has been measured and what has not, then gives you tools to choose an amount, a refund window and a scope you would be happy to explain to a guest.
What the data says about deposits
In the Resos data, reservations that required a payment guarantee recorded a 0.80% no-show rate. Reservations with no payment requirement recorded 2.47%.
Recorded no-show rate, with and without a payment requirement
Hover or tab through the bars for detail.
Source: Resos No-Show Index 2026, published 19 August 2026. Resos publishes these as raw descriptive rates only: restaurants that ask for deposits differ from those that do not, so the gap cannot be put down to the deposit itself.
Read that carefully. The gap is large, but it is not proof that a deposit would cut your no-shows by the same amount.
The other side has not been measured anywhere we could verify: how many guests decide not to book because a deposit is asked for. That is the number you have to estimate, and then check, for your own room.
Not every restaurant wants one. At Gymkhana Riyadh, card guarantees are asked only for private dining and groups of 12 or more.
“Asking a loyal guest for a guarantee sends the wrong message.”
Is it worth it for your room?
A deposit pays off if the no-shows it avoids are worth more than the bookings it puts off. This calculator compares the two. The no-show rate starts at 3% and the deposit effect at 68%, which is the gap between the two Resos rates above. That effect is a raw association, not proven cause, so move it. Bookings put off starts at 0% because we have no measured figure to offer. Set it to your own estimate.
Deposit trade-off
- No-shows avoided per month (assumed)
- 20.4
- Worth
- $2,448
- Bookings put off per month
- 0.0
- Cost
- $0
- Net per month
- $2,448
- Break-even: bookings you can afford to lose
- 2.04%
Net = (bookings x no-show rate x assumed drop - bookings x share put off) x spend per party. Assumes an avoided no-show becomes a seated table.
Source: Resos No-Show Index 2026, published 19 August 2026. Used for the 3% starting rate and the 68% starting effect. Raw rates, not proven cause.
Look at the break-even line. At a 3% no-show rate, even the full measured gap is worth about 2% of your bookings. If a deposit puts off more than that, it costs more than it saves. The higher your own no-show rate, the more room you have.
The four decisions
1. How much?
Think of the deposit as a share of a typical bill, not as an absolute number. Try values below.
Deposit as a share of the bill
- Deposit collected
- $40
- Typical bill
- $180
- Deposit as share of bill
- 22%
Share = (deposit per guest x party) / (spend per guest x party). Pick a share you would be comfortable explaining to a guest.
2. Refundable until when?
Match the window to how far ahead you can still re-offer a table. Look at your own book: how late do replacement bookings come in? A room that fills on the day can offer a short window. A room that books out weeks ahead needs a longer one.
3. For whom?
You can ask everyone, or only the bookings where an empty table hurts most. In the Resos data, parties of 10 or more were recorded as no-shows less often than parties of one or two (1.15% against 2.63%). But each large no-show took far more covers with it: 13.44 on average against 1.96 (Resos No-Show Index 2026, 19 August 2026).
4. What happens to it?
Decide whether the deposit comes off the bill when the guest dines or is refunded afterwards, and say so. Either way, a guest who shows up has paid nothing extra.
Build your policy
Choose your settings and read the sentence a guest would see. If it sounds harsh to you, change it until you would agree to it yourself.
Deposit policy builder
What your guest sees
A deposit of $10 per guest is required for bookings of 4 or more guests. It comes off your final bill when you dine with us. Cancel at least 24 hours before your reservation for a full refund. Later cancellations and no-shows lose the deposit.
A clear amount, a stated window, and a threshold that covers your larger tables. Check the window against how late your replacement bookings come in.
How TableShift handles deposits
In TableShift, a refundable deposit is paid to your own Stripe account when the guest books. You can require one on every booking, or request one on a single booking, such as a large group.
Life of a deposit
The policy is shown before payment, in plain words, not buried in terms.
Launch it carefully
- Start narrow. Large groups or your busiest nights first.
- Tell regulars. A short note is better than finding out at checkout.
- Compare before and after. Track your no-show rate and your booking count for a month each side, then adjust the amount or the window.
Check your understanding
0/31. What makes a deposit policy clear to a guest?
2. In the Resos data, parties of 10 or more were recorded as no-shows less often than parties of one or two. Why might a restaurant still ask only large groups for a deposit?
3. Resos reports 0.80% no-shows with a payment requirement and 2.47% without. What can you conclude?
Finished the quiz already? Or skip it and mark this lesson done.
Put it into practice with TableShift
Your own booking page and website widget, refundable deposits paid to your own Stripe account, email reminders, a floor plan with live seating and a staff-run waitlist. The Starter plan is free.