Gift card breakage: what it is and how restaurants account for it
What gift card breakage is
Breakage is the value on gift cards that is sold and never redeemed. A guest buys a $50 card, the recipient spends $42 and loses the card, and $8 stays on your books. That $8 is breakage.
It matters for two reasons. It affects when you may count gift card money as revenue, and in some states the unredeemed balance does not belong to you at all. This guide covers both, with the accounting rule quoted from its source and a calculator you can check against a published example. It is general information, not accounting or legal advice.
A gift card sale is not revenue yet
When you sell a gift card you receive cash and hand over a promise. You owe the holder a meal. In your accounts that promise is a liability, not a sale. It becomes revenue when the card is redeemed and you serve the food.
That is why a strong December for gift cards does not show up as December revenue. The cash arrives in December. The revenue arrives when the cards are spent, which can be months later.
When breakage becomes revenue
Under US accounting rules, the paragraph that governs this is ASC 606-10-55-48. PwC's revenue guide quotes it and explains it. There are two cases.
- You expect breakage and can estimate it. You recognize the expected breakage as revenue “in proportion to the pattern of rights exercised by the customer”. In plain terms: as guests redeem, you recognize the same share of your expected breakage. PwC's example is that an entity recognizes 50 percent of the total estimated breakage once 50 percent of customer rights have been redeemed.
- You do not expect to be entitled to breakage. You recognize it only when the likelihood of the customer redeeming the rest becomes remote.
Between the two sits the business that cannot tell whether there will be breakage, or how much. For that case the guide says to apply the limit on estimates of variable consideration, which can still mean recording a minimum amount. That is a judgment for your accountant.
The guide then works a restaurant example. Restaurant Inc sells 1,000 gift cards at $50 each, so $50,000 in total. From its history with similar cards it expects 10% never to be redeemed, which is $5,000, leaving $45,000 it expects to be redeemed. In the next year guests redeem $22,500. That is half of the $45,000, so half of the $5,000 breakage is recognized. Revenue for the year is $22,500 plus $2,500, which is $25,000.
The calculator below opens on those figures. Change them to your own.
How much breakage counts as revenue so far?
You expect $45,000 to be redeemed in the end. Guests have redeemed 50% of that, so the same share of your expected breakage counts as revenue: $2,500.
The starting figures are the restaurant example in PwC's revenue guide (Example RR 7-12): $50,000 of cards sold, 10% expected breakage and $22,500 redeemed, giving $25,000 of revenue. The breakage rate is your own estimate. We quote no typical rate because we have no source for one. The sum assumes none of the unredeemed value has to be handed to a state as unclaimed property.
Where the breakage rate comes from
From your own records. In PwC's example the 10% is “based on history with similar gift cards”. A restaurant that has sold gift cards for five years can look at what was sold in year one and what has been redeemed since.
A new program has no history of its own to point to, which makes an estimate harder to support. Ask your accountant how to treat breakage until you have one. We quote no typical breakage rate in this article, because we have not found one with a source we can check.
The estimate is not fixed. The guide says it should be updated at each reporting period, with the liability adjusted to match. If guests redeem more than you expected, your rate was too high and it has to come down.
The catch: unclaimed property laws
Some states treat a gift card balance that sits unredeemed for years as abandoned property that must be handed to the state. This is called escheat. PwC's guide is direct about the effect: a business “should not recognize estimated breakage as revenue” on money that must be remitted to a government body if the customer never asks for it.
The rules differ a great deal. These are the statute summaries in the National Conference of State Legislatures list for five states:
- New York. Unredeemed gift certificates that have gone unclaimed for five years are abandoned property, to be paid to the state comptroller.
- Florida. An unredeemed gift certificate does not have to be reported as unclaimed property. The money paid for it belongs to the issuer.
- Washington and Illinois. Gift certificates are excluded from the definition of property in the unclaimed property law.
- California. Gift certificates bought after 1997 are not subject to escheat, except one that has an expiry date and was given in exchange for money.
Breakage and expiry are different things
An expiry date is a rule about the card. Breakage is an estimate about behavior. A card that never expires can still produce breakage in your accounts, because the accounting turns on what you expect guests to redeem, not on a date printed on the card.
The two do meet in one place. A gift card covered by the federal rule cannot expire for at least five years, and in some states not at all, so you cannot create breakage by setting a short expiry. The rules are in do restaurant gift cards expire?
What to Track
You cannot estimate breakage, or answer your accountant, without four numbers. Keep them from the first card you sell.
- Sold. The value of cards sold, by month.
- Redeemed. The value spent, by month, and ideally by the month the card was sold.
- Outstanding. The total still unredeemed. This is your liability.
- Free value. Bonus or promotional value you gave away, kept apart from value guests paid for.
A paper log of gift certificates makes this hard, which is one practical argument for selling cards through a system that records every sale and redemption. If you are choosing one, see how to start a gift card program.
What TableShift shows you
For gift cards sold through TableShift, the dashboard shows the balance you still owe on unredeemed cards, what was sold and redeemed over time, bonus value issued in promotions, and the balance left on cards that have expired or been disabled.
It does not estimate breakage for your accounts, and it does not file unclaimed property reports. Those are decisions for you and your accountant. The dashboard gives you the figures to make them with.
Check your understanding
0/31. You sell $10,000 of gift cards and expect 10% never to be redeemed. Guests have redeemed $4,500. How much breakage counts as revenue so far?
2. When you sell a gift card, what do you record?
3. Your state treats unredeemed gift card balances as unclaimed property. What happens to that value?